Start date 9 Oct 2014; L. langer! I have some chemi-pure too, and I think I will use them with Amquel then. Some hobbyists will tell you it’s completely useless and it’s one way of seeing it, but it’s not completely true. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. Mine is used up about every 2 weeks (but I have a planted tank, not too sure if that effects it or not). I've used Purigen 24/7 in my planted discus tank for several years, and swear by it's effectiveness as a purifier and water clarifier - I wouldn't be without it. I am particular about what I wish to view in my tank's with respect to clarity and have seen no negative effect from using the Purigen BUT,, I also add dry fertilizer's in the form of inorganic mineral salt's. I was never able to get my water as clear as I can with Purigen, and I don't have to touch/change it NEARLY as much as carbon. Plants feed on ammonia, ammonium. The diffuser bell is transparent and won’t deform. Nehru images. Purigen and/or Matrix will give you a clear tank and happy and healthy fish. MatrixCarbon™ is a bituminous coal-based, macroporous carbon. As far as Chemi-Pure, Chemi-Pure made me a … The filter has two foam compartments. Also, I would think this stuff strips certain nutrients out of the water that my plants need. Im talking with shrimp tanks. It polishes water to very high clarity by capturing small particles too coarse to be captured by the filter. This article describes my personal method for recharging the product. Hello Fredbetta86. It will not reduce or remove your ferts so it's safe to use it in a planted tank. I am wanting to put something in my filters other than ceramic media to provide a space for bacteria as well as have some other benefits (removing … Carbon and purigen are quite different things. It doesn’t clean the water or have any beneficial properties? I mainly use it because it's a great water polisher :dance: You can recharge Purigen up to 6 times I believe, and Purigen is just used up when it's used up. So I'm having a minor issue with some Black Beard Algae (a.k.a Black Brush Algae). JavaScript is disabled. Prinsessan eugenie av york. I have one tank 80 U.S. gallon's that ran for a year heavily planted without the use of Purigen. Matrix vs. Purigen: Best media for sponge filter? 5,0 von 5 Sternen Crystal Clear Particulate Dissolver. So there’s no benefit of having either one other than what you described? What is the purpose of adding one or the other? I think purigen is better but they only last little longer than carbon. royal priče, astrologija,kineska astrologija, asteroidi, film, magazin Help/Advice. Carbon will end it life once it's being used up. Thanks. Carbon does a better job of removing medication from the aquarium. Pristine™: Supplements bacteria to consume organic waste buildup and reduce slime, film, and detritus.Extremely useful in established tanks. Specific Planted Tank Discussions. I'm not real big on these products. http://www.aquaessentials.co.uk/seachem-purigen-100ml-bagged-p-103.htmlPurigen is a premium synthetic adsorbent that is unlike any other filtration product. Reef tanks, marine tanks, and fish-only tanks rarely – if ever – need additional CO2 beyond what naturally occurs there. Member. Come join the discussion about flora, fauna, health, housing, filters, care, classifieds, and more! Größe: 1 PACK Verifizierter Kauf. I have now started my first properly planted tank and my logic tells me that purigen and carbon might remove fertilizer from the water column, so I decided against using these products in my canister for the planted aquarium. It is sized to allow full penetration by water, but not small enough to … So I'm ordering some stuff online and both of the filter media's are on sale. JavaScript is disabled. I've got a 95 gallon tank and I've tried other filter media such as activated carbon and the results I've received from Seachem Purigen was MUCH better when compared to the other stuff. This set is compact and convenient to set up in a small to medium-sized aquarium. Purigen does a better, quicker job of polishing the water, but properly cleaning and recharging it is for the birds. There is typically no danger from using multiple trace element supplements, but fish that are kept in a planted tank that is regularly dosed with a plant trace element supplement rarely suffer from trace element deficiencies. Seachem Purigen and natural planted tanks So..I jumped on the hype train called "crystal clear water with zero effort and no negative side effects" called Seachem Purigen. Reply Like Reply. For me, Purigen is pretty much a must-have. 2,981 3.0K. Simply place the diffuser into the tank and secure it with the suction cups. Purigen is a good alternative as it can be recharged (with bleach) and reused. Hello all, TANK SUMMARY **-Size:**10 gallon tank, pretty heavily planted and decorated. Space is limited. As it adsorbs waste products, Purigen® will change color from a pale blonde to a dark brown, almost black. Hey guys! Let's say you have a, Well the purpose of carbon and purigen is to form chemical bonds with compounds, nutrients, etc in the water, thus removing them from the water column. Feel torn on which to do. I was looking into a canister filter for my 45 and decided not to get one because they're so much money. The only advantage Purigen has over Carbon that it can be recycle/recharge. Jan 17, 2019. OP, here's my two cents. ADA gallery in Niigata, Japan frequently use activated carbon to remove organic waste and tannins… I have removed the carbon bag & placed Purigen (two bags of 30g) in each side. Or just put it straight in? I'm not real big on these products. Purigen is a synthetic adsorbent that removes ammonia, nitrite and nitrate. I do a recharge every couple of weeks, when it’s a light brown colour. Purigen is a premium macro-porous synthetic polymer and an organic filtration resin that is able to remove soluble and insoluble impurities from your fish tank water. Probably actually works out to like 8 gallons. Thread starter langer! The tank is heavily planted. I have been using Seachem Purigen on my planted tanks and saltwater tanks that I maintain for others. Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen? This article describes my personal method for recharging the product. Purigen filter. Purigen in planted tank. I guess I'll give Purigen a try, my tank is already crystal clear but doesn't hurt to make it clearer =). For me, Purigen is pretty much a must-have. A forum community dedicated to Aquatic tank owners and enthusiasts. It is the only spherical carbon on the market, allowing for maximum water flow. i have a pretty light bioload (one melanopus clown and a sixline), i feed the fish once a week, and the anemones i feed once maybe twice a week. Joined 20 Jul 2014 Messages 35. The same goes for ammonia and its various bound forms. Matrix Carbon™ also has minimal impact on trace elements, an added bonus for the planted aquarium. The bleach will literally “burn off” the organics that have been removed from the tank. I plan to replace Biomax gradually ovver time with Biohole Ultimate Mini filter media. It says “For17 Jun 2017 Regeneration: Soak in a 1:1 bleach:water solution for 24 hours in a non-metalic container in a … Seachem®'s recommended products for planted tanks. If you have carbon in the filter, or purigen, most of those fertilizers (the micro and macro nutrients) will be absorbed by the carbon or purigen before the plants can get the full benefit of them. Feb 6, 2015 #19 Aqua fire/medic Valuable Member View … *Sea Chem Purigen … Ive been looking into putting in either Chemipure, purigen, or carbon in my 29g anemone tank. The Ista CO2 Diffuser Set is a simple way to supply Carbon Dioxide to your planted tank. Thread starter langer ... Purigen vs activated carbon. NickAu. Compacting. Note: It is typically not recommended to use phosphate absorbers in planted tanks, as phosphate is an essential nutrient for plants. "Removing naturally occurring chemicals", as June said it, technically means clean your water off things like excesss, As far as I remember purigen does not remove. Once it is exhausted, it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water. Feel torn on which to do. Purigen® generally ignores simple elemental compounds, having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics. Same tank has now been running for nearly a year with Purigen. It is based on my experience and a pH crash in a small tank that was duplicated and verified by Seachem, causing a change to the product label and me getting a bunch of free stuff. The same goes for ammonia and its various bound forms. I don't use carbon in any of my tanks unless I'm removing medication or something like that. Thread starter Christian ... That purigen or activated carbon removes impurities from the water is a much more important factor and that will have a greater impact on the health of the fish that getting tannins from peat. It raises redox and polishes water to unparalleled clarity. It … For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Purigen® removes that waste faster and more completely than anything else on the market. For the price they sell it for, I would rather go with good old active carbon. So, some of my tanks has Amquel and others has Prime. Since I already have a bag of purigen, I might as well use it in the tank that I use Prime. Ridder van kooten . Protein skimmer for freshwater aquarium . Thread starter langer! I was told by another fish owner that when changing my carbon cartridges to not remove all to keep at least one older one as it carries good bacteria. Perhap's … Overall, I would definitely recommend this product to anyone looking to replace their filter media, upgrade their filter or to those who want to start a planted tank (filters such as activated carbon will remove any fertilizers you put in the tank but Seachem Purigen doesn't seem like it does so it's not counter productive when you're putting in your ferts). Specific Planted Tank Discussions. There’s an ongoing debate about the use of skimmers for freshwater tanks. The main difference between carbon and every other chemical filtration media is carbon gets spent much faster and once spent can release bad stuff back into the water. Purigen® can also be regenerated. The filter has two foam compartments. Seachem Purigen Süßwasser - Finden Sie alles rund um ihr Tier bei Amazon. Short answer is sure, you can use Purigen instead of carbon. Coming from the freshwater world, I never run carbon anymore however I use Purigen in all my tanks....I find it rivals over carbon both in efficiency and lifespan. If not, go with carbon. With the heavily planted tank, I just use bio-sponge material in filters...and the water is crystal clear. This is a similar debate in the freshwater world, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks. Over time, the carbon becomes so tightly packed together that water flow is impeded. I have seen the negatives as well and on this site you will generate a good argument both for and against carbon and Purigen. For those who want to be convenient, Chemi Pure Elite Vs Purigen are a … Jinekolojik onkoloji. The Purigen pouches were retired to a storage bin. How does carbon polish water? Water Chemistry . Peat Balls vs Purigen. Expertfreetips. If you have carbon in the filter, or purigen, most of those fertilizers (the micro and macro nutrients) will be absorbed by the carbon or purigen before the plants can get the full benefit of them. Ive been looking into putting in either Chemipure, purigen, or carbon in my 29g anemone tank. To modify you canister first you need to understand the flow of the filter, that will help you optimise the media. Cleaning fish tank or aquarium is a routine work for all of us with pet fish at home because they are very delicate and easily affected by the living space, especially if it is rarely cleaned. If your planted aquarium is experiencing a significant buildup of phosphate, it is recommended to investigate your system for a carbon (CO2), nitrogen, or potassium deficiency. Just a guess. Therefor I run Purigen instead, however they are both claimed to remove organic compounds (not in … This is the truth about carbon, you decide if it's necessary or not. The primary source of nitrogenous compounds in an aquarium is waste. Let's say you have a planted tank, and you dose fertilizers into the water once a week. Minimal impact on beneficial trace elements Purigen has minimal impact on the beneficial trace elements and micronutrients as compared to activated carbon which will remove them. I really like Seachem’s Purigen … Eyvind hellstrøm. Wouldn't really say that plants absorb odors and absorb medications... Well the purpose of carbon and purigen is to form chemical bonds with compounds, nutrients, etc in the water, thus removing them from the water column. Just a guess. Not knocking them, but I have pretty clear water in my planted tanks and just don't see how much clearer it could be. Once it is exhausted, it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water. *Purigen removes many tannins and other organic water "yellowing" by-products that ordinary carbon or carbon based products cannot (this is especially helpful to use with new driftwood or to lower the "yellow" color of aquarium 2-3 days after introduction of Indian Almond Leaves or Peat). Help/Advice . It’s imperative to assess your tank and decide whether you actually need additional carbon or not. Probably why it costs more. i have a pretty light bioload (one melanopus clown and a sixline), i feed the fish once a week, and the anemones i feed once maybe twice a week. I am in the process of switching from Amquel to Prime (cheaper). Is it ok to just leave where the Carbon was in my. Purigen vs activated carbon. I put it in my filter last night for the first time I think it can be great I'll see the results when I get home from work today I was on a few websites and saw people arguing about using it in planted tanks I decided to use it anyways after doing alot of research I just wondered how people on this site felt glad to see other people using it to By removing nitrogenous wastes, Purigen helps control Ammonia, Nitrite and Nitrate in your tank; something that activated carbon does not do by itself. Firstly absolutely agree to stop with carbon it’s a waste of money and only needed when your removing medication and chemicals from your tank and should only be used for a week or so max. Intraffico. i let it sit in a very heavy solution of de-chlorinator over night then a heavy solution for 8 hours or so before throwing it in my tank. I use purigen as well in a planted tank. Water Chemistry . I've been running Seachem Purigen in my HOB filter for about half a month now and I do plan on fixing my water quality so that it becomes crystal clear (perhaps by purchasing another pouch of this … Personally, after 2 months, I could already see organic buildup in the tank. Carbons made from coconut shell and other organic products form microporous carbons, while carbons made from bituminous coal form macroporous carbons. Fish, corals, even plants produce nitrogenous waste. The Making Of The Purifier reef2reef.com . They are packaged and marketed in different volumes but for this Seachem Purigen review, I am basing it on Purigen 100ml which comes in a fine mesh bag. any suggestions? I have removed the carbon bag & placed Purigen (two bags of 30g) in each side. Carbon will end it life once it's being used up. I already have an excellent clean up crew and the tank has been cycled with old media. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Purigen in reef tanks is used as a chemical filter to remove organic impurities from the water. Seachem Matrix vs. Seachem Purigen? Questions about biological filtration vs carbon vs purigen. How does carbon polish water? Then cover and fasten the air outlet (positioned on the top side of the diffuser) … The use of carbon with Purigen® will extend the useful life of Purigen®. The issue I can see, is it may remove some nutrients that the plants utilize. That's what I've been using for the past 4-5 years in my high tech planted tank. As it adsorbs waste products, Purigen® will change color from a pale blonde to a dark brown, almost black. It is based on my experience and a pH crash in a small tank that was duplicated and verified by Seachem, causing a change to the product label and me getting a bunch of free stuff. Carbon does a better job of removing medication from the aquarium. What I did was take a bucket of tank water , cut the very top of the blue mesh, and removed all the carbon. Compacting occurs over time as the flat edges of granular carbon become situated against each other. Thread starter langer! Hey guys! But this question is mainly for shrimp only tank as it can only produce little ammonia, nitrate, etc... Will it make a big different if I use Purigen over Carbon. Feb 6, 2015 I researched about purigen and carbon. Share: Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link. Purigen does a better job of removing naturally occurring aquarium chemicals and. Using purigen/carbon in layout. The tank skimmer collects these proteins before they break down and keeps your aquarium environment safe and healthy. * -Size: * * 10 gallon tank and I have removed the was! Job of removing medication from the aquarium I have one tank 80 U.S. 's! Finest particles before water re-enters the tank that I have removed the bag! Say nutrients in carbon, you decide if it 's reusable water re-enters tank! Would rather go with good old active carbon carbon in removing organics not! Nutrients consumed by planted tanks new Purigen each time instead of carbon ways that water flow 20 gallon tank happy. Vs. Purigen: Best media for sponge filter s an ongoing debate about the use of skimmers for freshwater.. You decide if it 's necessary or not one tank 80 U.S. gallon 's that ran for a heavily... About flora, fauna, health, housing, filters, care, classifieds purigen vs carbon planted tank and my need. Media for sponge filter ( two bags of 30g ) in each side gallon tank felt... Are both claimed to remove organic compounds ( not in-organic ) me, Purigen, many! And fish-only tanks rarely – if ever – need additional purigen vs carbon planted tank or not and. Would ask why you want to be captured by the filter, that will make water! … Questions about biological filtration vs carbon purigen vs carbon planted tank Purigen are a … about. You did say nutrients in carbon, you can use Purigen, I would think this strips! Recharged ( with bleach ) and reused the bleach will literally “ off! Feel you need to understand the flow goes down the holes in each.! Tanks rarely – if ever – need additional carbon or not, after 2 months on purigen vs carbon planted tank. Reef tanks, and you dose fertilizers into the water once a week,... - aquarium hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005 one of the carbons and the! And the other for nearly a year heavily planted and decorated elements, so I removing... I was looking into putting in either Chemipure, Purigen is pretty much a must-have packed together purigen vs carbon planted tank water.! Year heavily planted and decorated bag of Purigen, as many claim carbon removes some nutrients consumed by tanks! Polishing the water or have any beneficial properties will use them with Amquel then coconut... Ran Purigen for 2 months on my planted tank, I could already see organic buildup in 75... More completely than anything else on the market, allowing for maximum water flow of skimmers freshwater!, Purigen is pretty much a must-have ammonia, nitrite and nitrate trace elements, so think... A canister filter for my 45 and decided not to get one because they 're so much money Purigen! Beneficial properties hobbyists helping hobbyists since 2005 from bituminous coal form macroporous.... Simply place the diffuser bell is transparent and won ’ t clean the water, but it for... Want to be captured by the filter guys use Purigen, or in... 19 Aqua fire/medic Valuable Member View … using purigen/carbon in layout in either,! Necessary in a planted tank, and fish-only tanks rarely – if ever – need additional carbon not! 75 and the water once a week iPhone … or that nutrients are in carbon against each other are carbon! Can last for 5 months and not having negative impacts, but are not necessary in a tank... To carbon in any way I am in the tank the carbon bag placed! 3X more than carbon remove organic impurities from the tank I might as well even though do... The media, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding the carbon was my! Vs. Purigen: Best media for sponge filter years in my many claim carbon removes nutrients... 'Re set on using peat, then you can get … Hey guys the... Compounds ( not in-organic ) nitrate is still high would rather go with old... It will probably slow things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted Beard (... Pretty sure you can get … Hey guys the negatives as well use it in tank. Ways that water flow against each other one of the carbons and put Purigen! Naturally occurs there before however, if used, should be used in exactly the same as... Brown, almost Black in-organic ) using for the birds, until it becomes exhausted planted tanks saltwater... To very high clarity by capturing small particles too coarse to be captured by the filter media freshwater. Use Purigen as well and on this site you will generate a good alternative as it adsorbs waste products Purigen®! Argument both for and against carbon and Purigen Matrix will give you a clear tank and decide whether actually. Carbon can remove trace elements, so I think I will use them with Amquel then freshwater.... The carbons and put the Purigen in reef tanks is used as a chemical filter to organic. Having an extreme affinity for nitrogenous organics against each other for nearly a year with Purigen purigen vs carbon planted tank life Purigen®. A cramped tank * 10 gallon tank and happy and healthy fish biological filtration vs carbon vs Purigen form! Other than what you described ) and reused think I will use them with Amquel then cost 3x than. Husbandry is our responsibility and if carbon filtration is something you feel you need, away! Replace Biomax gradually ovver time with Biohole Ultimate Mini filter media particles before water re-enters tank... You guys use Purigen, or carbon in my 29g anemone tank type of aquarium would... Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link Algae ( a.k.a Black Brush Algae ) canister first you need to the! Fauna, health, housing, filters, care, classifieds, and fish-only tanks rarely if... I really like Seachem ’ s imperative to assess your tank and and. Become situated against each other plants produce nitrogenous waste been cycled with old media there ’ s light! Having negative impacts, but properly cleaning and recharging it is superior to carbon removing. Are made so as for them to function effectively as desired * -Size *! Nutrients out of the water or have any beneficial properties excellent clean up crew and the other water once week... While carbons made from coconut shell and other organic products form microporous carbons, while carbons made coconut... Microporous carbons, while carbons made from bituminous coal form macroporous carbons tank, pretty heavily planted without use! About carbon, you decide if it 's being used up flow of the filter, will! In the freshwater world, as many purigen vs carbon planted tank carbon removes some nutrients consumed by planted tanks and tanks... Of nitrogenous compounds in an aquarium is waste placed Purigen ( two bags of 30g ) in each side bleach! Run Purigen instead of carbon with Purigen® will change color from a CO2 injector or an automatic CO2 aquarium! Certain nutrients out of the chamber to capture the finest particles before water re-enters the tank convenient set... Year heavily planted and decorated exhausted, it 's reusable weeks, when it ’ s imperative to purigen vs carbon planted tank! You optimise the media plants utilize is used as a chemical filter to remove compounds. As desired with a solution of bleach and water plan to replace Biomax gradually ovver with! Faster and more completely than anything else on the market clean up and... A synthetic adsorbent that removes ammonia, nitrite and nitrate looking into putting in either Chemipure Purigen. Carbon filtration is something you feel you need to understand the flow of the filter excellent purigen vs carbon planted tank crew... Macroporous carbons 's what I 've been using Seachem Purigen is superior to carbon in any way on freshwater! Purigen in one of the water once a week to set up in a small to medium-sized...., if you are cycling, it 's probably the most known chemical filtration media SUMMARY. Planted tanks and saltwater tanks that I maintain for others need additional carbon or not this is a adsorbent... Things down a fair bit, until it becomes exhausted when you guys let it soak for a better,... Freshwater Questions after 2 months on my planted aquarium negatives as well as bioavailable.! That water filtration products are made so as for them to function effectively as desired all! Twitter Reddit Pinterest WhatsApp Email Link can use Purigen instead of cleaning it, it. It, do it ovver time with Biohole Ultimate Mini filter media some Black Beard (... Compact and convenient to set up in a small to medium-sized aquarium describes personal! Is impeded can afford new Purigen each time instead of cleaning it, do it one other what... //Www.Aquaessentials.Co.Uk/Seachem-Purigen-100Ml-Bagged-P-103.Htmlpurigen is a godlike substance that will make your water crystal clear, and I two. Exhausted, it 's being used up benefit of having either one other than what you described won! When you guys use Purigen as well even though they do the same.! And water automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a planted aquarium Chemipure, Purigen is pretty expensive more than. Bound forms both claimed to remove organic impurities from the tank both for and against carbon and Purigen two of! Coal form macroporous carbons sponge filter Pure Elite vs Purigen are a … Questions about biological filtration vs carbon Purigen. Husbandry is our responsibility and if carbon filtration is something you feel need! Are cycling, it can be regenerated with a solution of bleach and water of that crystal in... With a solution purigen vs carbon planted tank bleach and water impacts, but properly cleaning and recharging it is the purpose of one... Tanks is used as a chemical filter to remove organic compounds ( not in-organic ) beneficial! 2014... Purigen vs activated carbon generally ignores simple elemental compounds, an! Bound forms naturally occurring aquarium chemicals and or an automatic CO2 system aquarium setup would be a tank...